Jimmy John’s, known for its “freaky fresh” and “freaky fast” reputation, is breaking into a new trend that’s all about… pickles! After recent launches like their throwback ‘90s-style starter jacket and the spicy Firecracker lineup, the sandwich chain is jumping on the dill bandwagon with a unique menu addition.
And yes, this one’s a real game-changer for pickle fans everywhere.
Here’s a complete scoop on Jimmy John’s first-of-its-kind Picklewich sandwich, plus an honest review of the new Turkey & Provolone Picklewich and its perfect pairing, the Pickle Jimmy Chips.
Introducing the Picklewich – Jimmy John’s Twist on a Dill Classic
Jimmy John’s Picklewich is unlike any other sandwich on their menu—and perhaps in the entire fast-food world. Instead of using bread, the sandwich comes wrapped in two halves of a giant kosher dill pickle. So, if you’re a pickle fan looking to skip the carbs or want a tangy upgrade to your regular order, this might be the sandwich.
The new Picklewich is available in two varieties:
1. The Vito Picklewich – A hollowed-out pickle stuffed with savory layers of salami, capicola, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, sauce, and Jimmy John’s unique blend of herbs.
2. Turkey & Provolone Picklewich—A giant dill pickle filled with turkey, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion, this is a fresh yet briny take on a classic deli favorite.
It’s possible that Jimmy John’s got the idea from a viral TikTok video showing a similar sandwich from the Seven Brothers Gourmet Food Market in Long Island, NY, which featured a deli-style pickle stuffed with meats, cheeses, and toppings.
Now, pickle lovers don’t have to go to New York to enjoy this salty, briny experience because Jimmy John’s is rolling out the Picklewich at locations nationwide.
Starting October 28, you can order the Picklewich in-store or for freaky-fast delivery. However, if you want to try it, you must be quick—these sandwiches are only available until November 14. And for an extra zesty pairing, Jimmy John’s is also bringing back its famous Pickle Jimmy Chips for a limited time. Dill-flavored chips are essential for anyone who loves that tangy, salty flavor.
Trying the Turkey & Provolone Picklewich: My Honest Review
As a die-hard pickle enthusiast, I jumped to try the new Turkey & Provolone Picklewich. I’ve always asked, “Are you going to eat your pickle?” whenever I see one left on a friend’s plate. And if fried pickles are on the menu, I’m ordering them. So, this new addition was right up my alley.
That said, I did have a couple of concerns going in. I wondered if it would be too messy and too “wet” from all the pickle brine. But I had to try it to find out.
First Impressions: Smaller Size and Bold Flavors
Right away, I noticed that the Picklewich was smaller than Jimmy John’s usual subs, which makes sense, given it’s made from a pickle rather than a loaf of bread.
It comes wrapped tightly in paper, which is necessary to keep everything in place while eating. Otherwise, you might have briny juices everywhere, so don’t toss the wrapper.
The first bite was delicious, which wasn’t surprising—if you love pickles, a turkey and cheese sandwich with extra pickles will always be a win.
The turkey and provolone contrasted with the tangy pickle, while the fresh veggies brought the whole thing together.
A Little Messy but Worth It
One of the main challenges with the Picklewich was its messiness. The pickle brine was dripping, and I had to work hard to keep the fillings from slipping out the back. But if you can handle a bit of brine and don’t mind a hands-on eating experience, it’s a fun (and tasty) way to switch up your usual order.
I did miss Jimmy John’s signature fresh bread, which is a big part of what makes their sandwiches so good. However, for people who want to skip the bread or are looking for a low-carb option beyond lettuce wraps, the Picklewich is a flavorful alternative.
A New Addition to My Usual Order?
Will I be switching to the Picklewich as my new go-to? Probably not. But I’m thinking about adding an extra dill pickle to my regular sandwiches from now on—why not take the best of both worlds? And if you’re a die-hard pickle lover, I’d say the Vito Picklewich might be worth a try, too.
The extra meats in the Vito version might make it a bit heartier than the Turkey & Provolone.
Pickle Jimmy Chips: The Perfect Companion
Now, let’s talk about the Pickle Jimmy Chips. If you’re a fan of dill-flavored snacks, these chips might be some of the best you’ll find. They’re not your typical dill chips; they have a fresh, zesty dill flavor that’s hard to find in most commercial brands.
Plus, they’ve got that Jimmy John’s quality, with a satisfying crunch and just the right balance of salt and dill.
I wouldn’t mind if these chips stuck around on the menu permanently. They’re an ideal snack whether you get a Picklewich or add them to your usual sandwich order.
Should You Try the Picklewich?
So, is the Picklewich worth a try? If you love pickles, the answer is a resounding yes. This unique twist on a classic sandwich delivers a refreshing combination of flavors and a satisfying crunch, all while keeping things low-carb.
And with two varieties, you can go for the Turkey & Provolone for something lighter or try the Vito for a bit more protein.
However, this one might not be for you if you’re more about traditional sandwiches or don’t want to deal with a bit of a salty mess.
For those who can’t get enough pickles, though, the Picklewich is a fun, limited-time experience worth a taste.
Final Verdict: Will Picklewich Join Jimmy John’s Permanent Menu?
While the Picklewich is only available until November 14, it’s already making waves among pickle fans. And who knows? If it proves popular enough, maybe Jimmy John’s will bring it back as a regular option.
In the meantime, I’d recommend trying it while it’s around, especially if you’re looking for something new to spice up your regular order. Just ensure you’ve got some napkins on hand—and don’t forget those Pickle Jimmy Chips for the perfect dill-filled pairing.
So, are you ready to dive into the world of pickles? Head to your nearest Jimmy John’s starting October 28 to try out this one-of-a-kind sandwich while it’s still on the menu!