The 1950s were a golden era for American coin collecting. Some pennies from this decade, especially in uncirculated condition, have become valuable treasures for collectors and investors alike.
With unique errors, low mintages, and historical significance, these coins are highly sought after today, with a select few worth substantial amounts.
Let’s dive into the most notable uncirculated pennies from the 1950s, valued collectively at over $400,000.
1. 1955 Doubled Die Penny
The 1955 Doubled Die Penny is one of U.S. history’s most famous error coins. A noticeable doubling in the date makes this penny a standout, and only a limited number of these coins were produced before the error was caught.
- Notable Feature: Doubled date, creating a shadowed effect.
- Value (Uncirculated): $1,500 – $20,000
Collectors prize this penny not only for its error but also for its scarcity. A 1955 Doubled Die Penny in pristine, uncirculated condition can fetch thousands of dollars at auction.
2. 1958 Doubled Die Penny
Only a handful of 1958 Doubled Die Pennies exist, making them even rarer than the 1955 version. This extreme rarity has made the 1958 Doubled Die one of the most coveted Lincoln cents.
- Notable Feature: Doubled elements, similar to the 1955 version.
- Value (Uncirculated): $5,000 – $100,000
Only a few 1958 Doubled Die Pennies are believed to be circulating today. When one appears at auction in uncirculated condition, it commands a hefty price.
3. 1956-D Repunched Mint Mark (RPM) Penny
Minted in Denver, the 1956-D Repunched Mint Mark (RPM) Penny features a unique error where the “D” mint mark was stamped twice, creating a subtle but noticeable shift.
- Notable Feature: Double-stamped “D” mint mark.
- Value (Uncirculated): $250 – $2,000
While less well-known than the doubled die varieties, the RPM error makes the 1956-D penny a desirable collectible. High-grade uncirculated examples are precious.
4. 1953-S Penny
Produced at the San Francisco Mint, the 1953-S Penny is notable for its low mintage, making it a valuable collector’s item in uncirculated condition.
- Notable Feature: Low mintage.
- Value (Uncirculated): $50 – $500
Collectors often seek out the 1953-S Penny to complete their sets, and well-preserved coins are known to reach impressive prices.
5. 1954-S Penny
Like the 1953-S, the 1954-S Penny was also minted in San Francisco and is sought after for its relative scarcity in high grades.
- Notable Feature: Limited production.
- Value (Uncirculated): $50 – $400
Uncirculated examples of the 1954-S penny are prized by collectors and often command a premium, exceptionally when well-preserved.
6. 1959 Memorial Reverse Penny
Although technically outside the 1950s decade, the 1959 Memorial Reverse Penny marks a pivotal moment in U.S. coinage. This penny was the first to feature the Lincoln Memorial on the reverse side, replacing the wheat design.
- Notable Feature: First penny with the Lincoln Memorial on the reverse.
- Value (Uncirculated): $25 – $250
The 1959 Memorial Reverse Penny is highly valued in uncirculated condition due to its historical significance as the start of a new era in coin design.
7. 1950-D Penny
Minted in Denver, the 1950-D Penny is cherished by collectors, especially in high-grade uncirculated condition. The scarcity of uncirculated specimens adds to its value.
- Notable Feature: Produced at Denver Mint with a limited uncirculated population.
- Value (Uncirculated): $30 – $350
Collectors value this coin for its clean, original luster and rarity in high grades, making it a popular choice for anyone interested in mid-century pennies.
8. 1957-D Penny
The 1957-D Penny is another Denver-minted coin with significant value in uncirculated conditions. While commonly found in circulated grades, uncirculated examples are much rarer.
- Notable Feature: Sharp design and original luster in uncirculated grades.
- Value (Uncirculated): $15 – $200
Collectors prize the uncirculated 1957-D Penny for its condition, historical significance, and potential for appreciating value over time.
9. 1951-S Penny
With its low mintage, the 1951-S Penny is a valuable addition to any collection. It was minted in San Francisco and is notably more challenging to find in pristine, uncirculated condition.
- Notable Feature: Low mintage from San Francisco Mint.
- Value (Uncirculated): $20 – $300
The 1951-S Penny is highly sought after in higher grades and commands a substantial premium among collectors.
10. 1952-D Penny
The 1952-D Penny, another Denver-minted coin, is valued for its scarcity in high grades. Finding an uncirculated version of this penny is a prized opportunity for collectors.
- Notable Feature: Limited availability in high grades.
- Value (Uncirculated): $20 – $200
With its original mint luster, an uncirculated 1952-D Penny is worth a premium, and its value only grows as the coin becomes rarer over time.
Summary Table: Uncirculated 1950s Pennies and Their Values
| Year | Mint Mark | Notable Feature | Approximate Value (Uncirculated) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1955 | None | Doubled Die | $1,500 – $20,000 |
| 1958 | None | Doubled Die | $5,000 – $100,000 |
| 1956 | D | Repunched Mint Mark (RPM) | $250 – $2,000 |
| 1953 | S | Low mintage | $50 – $500 |
| 1954 | S | Limited production | $50 – $400 |
| 1959 | None | Memorial Reverse design | $25 – $250 |
| 1950 | D | Scarce in uncirculated | $30 – $350 |
| 1957 | D | Original luster | $15 – $200 |
| 1951 | S | Low mintage | $20 – $300 |
| 1952 | D | Rare in high grades | $20 – $200 |
FAQs
The value of these pennies comes from factors like low mintage, rare errors, and excellent condition. Uncirculated 1950s pennies, especially those with unique features, have become prized collectibles.
An uncirculated penny has no wear and retains its original luster. Look for sharp details in the design and a lack of surface scratches or dullness, as these are signs it has yet to circulate.
Not all uncirculated 1950s pennies are highly valued. However, specific years, mint marks, and error varieties—like the doubled die pennies—are especially valuable among collectors.
Uncirculated pennies can be sold through coin dealers, online marketplaces, auction houses, and coin shows. Collectors are usually interested in pennies with specific years and mint marks.
Store uncirculated pennies in a cool, dry place in protective coin holders or airtight containers to preserve their value. This helps prevent tarnishing and damage that can lower the coin’s worth.
READ MORE: Are the Seven Rare Kurmi Coins Valued at $10 Million in Your Collection?