Costco’s meat department is often praised for offering high-quality cuts, from premium beef brisket to mouthwatering bacon. However, the retailer’s beloved filet mignon has recently come under fire from shoppers, sparking widespread discussions on social media platforms like Reddit.
Filet mignon, known for its tender texture and milder flavor, is typically one of the most sought-after cuts of steak. However, numerous Costco customers have recently reported issues with how the store’s filet mignon is prepared and sold. Complaints about the quality, such as excessive fat, tough connective tissue, and poorly cut pieces, have become common among frustrated buyers.
Disappointing Filet Mignon Cuts Spark Social Media Outcry
In one of the latest posts on Reddit, a Costco shopper shared a photo of poorly cut filet mignon steaks they found during a recent trip to the store. They expressed disappointment, noting they couldn’t find a single well-cut filet in the selection.
“I can’t confidently say that I saw a single, well-cut filet mignon,” the shopper wrote, frustrated by the lack of quality.
Unfortunately, this wasn’t an isolated incident. Another Reddit user posted earlier in the week about a bad experience after purchasing an $82 pack of filet mignon from Costco.
They were dismayed that the package contained three end pieces, each with a significant amount of silverskin. This tough connective tissue is challenging to remove, making the meat more complicated to cook and enjoy.
“Was someone having a bad day, or is getting multiple tails normal?” the shopper asked, referring to the less desirable end pieces that should ideally not make it into a premium filet mignon package.
Fellow customers chimed in, stating that it is rare to find so many tail ends in one package, suggesting that the issue might result from poor packaging and butchering at specific Costco locations.
Shoppers Share Similar Experiences
The complaints didn’t stop there. Both Reddit posts quickly gained traction, with numerous Costco members sharing their disappointing experiences with the store’s filet mignon. Many echoed the same concerns about the quality and preparation of the meat.
“This is the number one reason I stopped buying filet from Costco,” commented one shopper. “I had to return three packages that were full of ends. They were nice enough about the return, but I got tired of dealing with it.”
Another Costco customer mentioned that they had seen similar issues across several different warehouse locations, noting that the filet mignon consistently appeared poorly cut and contained unwanted fat and tissue.
“We have four different Costcos close to us, and all their filets are cut this way. I tell my wife every time that Costco needs to change their style or the butcher,” they added.
These complaints suggest that the quality issues with Costco’s filet mignon may not be isolated to one location but could be a broader problem affecting multiple stores.
Why the Inconsistencies?
While the growing number of complaints is concerning, it’s important to note that these issues may only be present at some Costco locations.
Costco operates a decentralized model where individual warehouses handle their meat preparation, meaning the quality of filet mignon could vary significantly depending on the skill and care of the employees in the meat department.
Shoppers have suggested inspecting the filet mignon closely before purchasing, as the quality may differ from one pack to another. While Costco has a strong reputation for high-quality products, the filet mignon requires a more careful eye.
Previous Product Issues at Costco
The filet mignon isn’t the only Costco product that has recently faced criticism from members. Just a few weeks ago, shoppers voiced their concerns over another product—the Stonefire Mini Naan bread sold at the warehouse club.
Multiple customers reported that the naan was prone to growing mold within a few days of purchase, even when the bread was well within its expiration date.
Similarly, Costco’s bakery section was criticized for introducing more miniature chocolate muffins. Customers expressed disappointment not only with the reduced size but also with a perceived drop in overall quality compared to previous versions of the product.
What Can Costco Do to Address These Issues?
As more customers share their grievances, Costco may need to examine its meat department and bakery practices more closely. These recurring complaints could impact consumer trust if they aren’t addressed by a company known for its member satisfaction and high standards later.
The solution could involve better training for butchers at individual warehouses or tightening quality control measures across all locations to ensure that the premium cuts, like filet mignon, meet customer expectations. Proactively communicating with customers about ongoing efforts to resolve quality concerns could help Costco maintain its reputation.
What Should Shoppers Do?
If you’re planning to buy filet mignon at Costco, the best course of action is to carefully inspect the package before adding it to your cart. Look for visible silverskin or fatty pieces, and avoid packages with multiple end cuts, which are more challenging and less desirable.
If you encounter poor quality cuts after purchasing, remember that Costco has a solid return policy and will likely address the issue without hassle.
In the end, shoppers must remain vigilant when shopping for higher-priced cuts of meat at Costco, mainly when such issues have been reported. While many customers still enjoy great experiences with Costco’s meat department, extra caution is warranted when selecting filet mignon.
Time will tell whether Costco will address the growing dissatisfaction among its loyal customers. Until then, it might be wise to look closer before making your next steak purchase.
READ MORE: The Texas Restaurant That’s A Piece Of Horror Movie History