Reese’s, one of the most beloved names in candy, has a new flavor but needs to be met with the usual excitement. According to the food influencer account Snack Betch, Reese’s Red Velvet is set to hit shelves early next year and be released in the first quarter of 2025.
This new twist on the classic peanut butter cup is expected to debut just in time for Valentine’s Day with heart design packaging.
However, many fans have already expressed their doubts despite the excitement that they have yet to convey a new flavor. The combination of Reese’s signature milk chocolate and peanut butter with a red velvet-flavored crème has left some longtime fans scratching their heads, and comments online suggest that the launch may not live up to the hype.
Mixed Reactions to the New Flavor
Some Reese’s fans have wondered if this new Red Velvet version will add anything exciting to the brand. On social media, reactions have mainly been lukewarm. While a few people expressed enthusiasm for the Valentine’s Day-themed treat, many others needed clarification.
“Is this even real???” one skeptic wrote. Another fan bluntly stated, “It isn’t broken. Please stop trying to fix it,” while a third person declared, “For the first time, this one is a pass.”
The absence of cream cheese—a key ingredient in most red velvet recipes—was another sore point for fans. “So, no cream cheese peanut butter inside?” one person asked, seemingly disappointed. This omission seemed to reinforce the feeling among fans that this new release might not be as unique as intended.
A Potential “Miss” for Reese’s?
There’s also the criticism that Red Velvet itself is overhyped. One commenter pointed out, “Red velvet is just red-colored chocolate.” Another added, “So just a regular Reese’s dyed red then,” poking fun at what they see as a lackluster effort to innovate.
These critiques suggest that many consumers feel Reese’s might be making a mistake by changing something that doesn’t need fixing. Rather than introducing new flavors that may fall flat, fans prefer the classic Reese’s experience—the familiar combination of peanut butter and chocolate that has made the brand a favorite for decades.
The Demand for Unique and Authentic Flavors
The commentary on Reese’s Red Velvet reveals that candy lovers are increasingly seeking new and unique experiences—but only if the flavors feel authentic and well thought out.
One of the most common complaints was that Red Velvet Reese’s doesn’t seem to offer anything truly different, with fans expressing concern that it may simply be a gimmick for the Valentine’s Day season.
Red velvet is often associated with rich, moist cake complemented by the tang of cream cheese frosting. The lack of that signature cream cheese flavor in this candy version disappoints fans who expect a more genuine red velvet experience. Without it, some feel that the new Reese’s flavor may come across as nothing more than a colored version of their regular product.
Reese’s Loyalists Aren’t Sold
Reese’s fans are known for their devotion to the brand, and this latest flavor announcement has left many loyalists scratching their heads. Reese’s core base isn’t necessarily looking for their favorite treat to be reinvented, primarily if the new version doesn’t deliver something fresh or exciting.
One fan summed it up with the comment, “It isn’t broken. Please stop trying to fix it.” This speaks to a broader sentiment that, while innovation is often welcome, it needs to be executed in a way that truly enhances the product rather than just offering a novelty twist.
M&M’s Is Winning Over Fans with Their New Treats
While Reese’s receives mixed feedback on its upcoming release, another candy brand generates buzz with its latest offerings. M&M’s has launched Peanut Butter M&M’s Ice Cream Sandwiches, which feature peanut butter ice cream between two sugar cookies filled with M&M’s Minis.
Fans are already praising this new treat, with many saying they can’t wait to try it.
In addition to its ice cream sandwiches, M&M will release a seasonal holiday flavor: Toasty Holiday Peanut M&M’s. These festive treats feature a blend of cinnamon, vanilla, spiced sugar, and caramel flavors, and fans eagerly await their release.
What Does the Future Hold for Reese’s Red Velvet?
While Reese’s Red Velvet may not be getting the warmest reception from fans, it’s worth remembering that sometimes new flavors take time to grow on people. Even if the initial feedback isn’t overwhelmingly positive, there’s always a chance that consumers will give it a try once it hits shelves and change their minds.
For now, though, it seems like Reese’s has its work cut out in convincing fans that this new flavor is worth the hype. With stiff competition from brands like M&M’s, Reese’s Red Velvet will need to bring something unique to win over candy lovers in 2025.
Conclusion:
The upcoming Reese’s Red Velvet flavor has sparked many reactions from fans, with many expressing disappointment and skepticism. While the packaging and timing suggest a Valentine’s Day release, the lack of cream cheese and the overall concept have left some fans wondering if this new flavor will be a hit or miss.
At the same time, other brands like M&M’s are finding success with innovative new products that deliver flavor and excitement. Only time will tell if Reese’s Red Velvet can live up to the challenge or if fans will stick with the classic peanut butter cup they know and love.
READ MORE: Reese’s Launched the Perfect Thanksgiving Dessert