If you’re a loyal Costco customer, you know one thing for sure: change isn’t always welcome. We like to stick to our warehouse shopping rituals—the $5 rotisserie chicken, free samples, and finishing the trip with a slice of cheese pizza. When things shift, it throws off our whole experience.
Well, brace yourself because a major change is happening in the bakery section. The muffins you’ve loved for years are getting a makeover. While this news might initially stir some outrage, the new muffins might be worth the buzz.
Costco’s Beloved Muffins Are Disappearing
First, let’s address the tough part: Costco discontinued its original muffin flavors. That means saying goodbye to your favorites like banana nut, apple crumb, vanilla chocolate chunk, and even the classic poppy seed.
But before you get upset, Costco is replacing them with four new flavors that are already making waves in some locations. So, what can you expect?
Say Hello to New Flavors
Costco is rolling out these fresh muffin varieties:
- Butter Pecan: Inspired by the rich ice cream flavor, this muffin features a sweet cinnamon crumble.
- Lemon Raspberry: A tangy and sweet combo topped with streusel.
- Triple Chocolate: An upgrade from the previous double chocolate muffin, this one has even more chocolate packed inside.
- Blueberry Cream: Taking the place of the classic blueberry muffin, this new version has a creamy twist.
Some Costco shoppers have already seen these new muffins in stores, and reviews—both good and bad — are starting to trickle in.
The Muffins Are Smaller, But There’s a Catch
You’re not alone if you’ve ever thought Costco’s muffins were more like small cakes. The new muffins will be a bit smaller than the jumbo-sized originals. But even with this trim, they’re still bigger than the average grocery store muffin.
The packaging is also getting a makeover. Instead of the old six-packs, where you had to buy two packs (12 muffins), the new muffins come in eight-count packages. This change may be welcome if you’ve ever struggled to finish all 12 muffins before they went bad.
A Price Change That Has People Talking
Now, let’s talk about the price. Previously, a dozen muffins cost $9.99. With the new eight-count packaging, you’ll pay $6.99.
At first glance, this might seem like a decent price drop. But when you break it down, you’re paying more per muffin—about $1.34 per pound compared to the old price.
Not surprisingly, this has sparked some outrage from Costco fans.
Fans Are Not Happy—and They’re Not Quiet About It
Costco enthusiasts are known for their loyalty—and their vocal opinions. Many took to social media to express their frustration about the muffin changes.
“Nooo, keep them the same!” one fan pleaded. Another declared, “You can’t take the churros AND the muffins from me.”
Some even threatened to revolt. “I’m not going to lie, this is rocking my world,” one user shared. I will personally start a revolt.”
Some customers are heartbroken over the changes. But not everyone is upset.
Some Customers Are Warming Up to the New Muffins
While the initial reactions were mostly negative, some shoppers are starting to see the bright side. For starters, the smaller packages mean less waste for customers who can’t finish 12 jumbo muffins before they go stale.
One shopper pointed out, “A big problem was the muffins would go bad before people could finish them. I don’t need 12 massive muffins; I usually only want one flavor anyway.”
Others are already fans of the new flavors. One Costco customer from Austin, Texas, raved about the Lemon Raspberry muffin, saying, “Tried the new muffins at the Austin Costco. The raspberry lemon is IT!”
Are the New Muffins an Upgrade?
It’s always tough to say goodbye to your favorite foods, especially ones that have been around for years. But based on early reviews, Costco might offer us an upgrade with these new muffins.
While the price increase stings a little, and the smaller size might feel like a downgrade, there are upsides. The new flavors are getting positive feedback, and the smaller packages might make more sense for people who don’t want a dozen huge muffins at once.
Plus, the quality of the ingredients seems to be improving. Some shoppers believe that the new muffins, despite being smaller, taste even better than the originals.
What’s Next for Costco Fans?
We’ll have to wait and see how the broader Costco fanbase receives these new muffins. It’s possible that, with time, the new flavors could become just as beloved as the originals. After all, change is never easy, but sometimes it leads to something better.
So, while this might be a tough adjustment for some, let’s try to stay optimistic. Who knows? These new muffins might just surprise you. And if all else fails, there’s always another seasonal bakery treat around the corner to look forward to.
In the end, whether you’re upset or excited about the changes, it’s clear that Costco’s bakery is always evolving. Just like the rotisserie chicken and the cheese pizza finale, the muffins will remain a central part of our Costco experience—even if they’re a little different than before.
Conclusion
Costco’s muffin makeover may have stirred up some drama, but it’s not the end of the world. Yes, we’re saying goodbye to some classic flavors, and the new muffins are smaller and pricier. However, early feedback suggests that the new flavors are delicious, and the smaller packaging could mean less waste.
So, Costco fans, let’s keep an open mind. These new muffins might just win us over—one bite at a time.
READ MORE: Thomas Holiday Treats Are Back!